HomeAI Startups Criticized for Using Peer Review as PR Tactic
A storm is brewing in the academic world over the use of AI-generated studies at this year's ICLR conference, a major event focused on artificial intelligence. Three AI labs, Sakana, Intology, and Autoscience, have stirred controversy by submitting AI-generated studies to ICLR workshops.
Sakana took a transparent approach, informing ICLR leaders and obtaining consent from peer reviewers before submitting their AI-generated papers. However, Intology and Autoscience did not follow suit, submitting their studies without prior notification, as confirmed by an ICLR spokesperson to TechCrunch.
The academic community has been vocal on social media, with many criticizing Intology and Autoscience for exploiting the peer review process. Prithviraj Ammanabrolu, an assistant professor at UC San Diego, expressed his frustration on X, highlighting the lack of consent from reviewers who provide their time and effort for free. He urged for full disclosure to editors about the use of AI in generating these studies.
Peer review is already a demanding task, with a recent Nature survey indicating that 40% of academics spend two to four hours reviewing a single study. The workload is increasing, as evidenced by the 41% rise in submissions to the NeurIPS conference last year, totaling 17,491 papers.
The issue of AI-generated content in academia is not new, with estimates suggesting that between 6.5% and 16.9% of papers submitted to AI conferences in 2023 contained synthetic text. However, using peer review as a means to benchmark and promote AI technology is a more recent development.
Intology boasted about receiving unanimously positive reviews for their AI-generated papers on X, even quoting workshop reviewers praising the "clever ideas" in one of their studies. This self-promotion did not sit well with academics.
Ashwinee Panda, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Maryland, criticized the lack of respect shown to human reviewers by submitting AI-generated papers without their consent. Panda noted that Sakana had approached her workshop at ICLR, but she declined to participate, emphasizing the importance of respecting reviewers' time and rights.
Skepticism about the value of AI-generated papers is widespread among researchers. Sakana acknowledged that their AI made "embarrassing" citation errors and that only one of their three submitted papers would have met the conference's standards. In a move towards transparency, Sakana withdrew their paper from ICLR.
Alexander Doria, co-founder of AI startup Pleias, suggested the need for a "regulated company/public agency" to conduct paid, high-quality evaluations of AI-generated studies. He argued that researchers should be fully compensated for their time and that academia should not be used as a free resource for AI evaluations.
Related article
Bayer Leverages Iambic AI to Speed Drug Discovery
Juergen Eckhardt, M.D., serves as Head of Business Development and Licensing at Bayer Pharmaceuticals.Bayer is leveraging Iambic Therapeutics to deploy frontier AI models for drug discovery, alongside a major decarbonization project at its plant in S
Optimization-Driven AI Emerges as New Path to General-Purpose Models
Researchers from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and the University of Virginia have created a new model architecture that could pave the way for more resilient AI systems with enhanced reasoning power.Named the energy-based transformer (
AI Boom Echoes Dot-Com Era Bubble Concerns
The influx of multi-billion dollar investments into AI has fueled a heated debate: is the industry headed for a dot-com style bubble?Investors are vigilant for any cooling of enthusiasm or signs that massive spending on chips and infrastructure isn't
Related Special Topic Recommendations
SEO
Best AI SERP Analysis Tools for Search Strategy
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI SERP Analysis Tools for Search Strategy are curated by XIX.AI through rigorous real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. These powerful tools help you unlock hidden optimization opportunities, boost content performance, and gain a competitive edge in search. Discover your perfect tool to elevate your search strategy today. Explore now!
13 tools
xix.ai
Data Analysis
Best AI Anomaly Detection Tools for KPI Monitoring across SaaS and Ecommerce Teams
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Anomaly Detection Tools for KPI Monitoring in SaaS and Ecommerce teams! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection based on rigorous real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison insights to help you identify the must-try solution that boosts productivity and unlocks your AI edge. Explore now!
10 tools
xix.ai
writing
Best AI Outline Generators for Long-Form SEO Articles
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Outline Generators for Long-Form SEO Articles, meticulously curated by XIX.AI. These powerful tools offer game-changing assistance in creating high-quality content quickly, boosting writing efficiency significantly. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and detailed rankings to help you find the must-try option that suits your needs. Explore now to unlock your AI edge.
8 tools
xix.ai
Education and Learning
AI Study Tools for Homework and Exam Prep
2026 Latest Best AI Study Tools for Homework and Exam Prep! XIX.AI curates a top-rated list of powerful, game-changing tools that help students boost productivity, streamline homework completion, and ace exams through real-world tests. Get a free vs paid comparison, detailed rankings, and must-try options to unlock your AI edge. Explore now!
10 tools
xix.ai
Music composition
AI Vocal Demo Tools for Songwriters, Hooks, Toplines, and Multilingual Draft Sessions
2026 Latest Best AI Vocal Demo Tools for Songwriters, Hook Creators, and Multi-Language Content Teams! XIX.AI has curated a top-rated list of powerful game-changing tools that go through rigorous real-world tests. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison data, comprehensive rankings, and must-try options to help you boost writing efficiency and unlock your creative potential. Explore now to discover your perfect tool for all your content needs!
9 tools
xix.ai
Business
Best AI Competitive Research Tools for Small Businesses
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Competitive Research Tools for Small Businesses! XIX.AI has curated a highly powerful game-changing collection, updated weekly with rigorous real-world tests and detailed rankings. You can find a comprehensive free vs paid comparison to help you identify the must-try tools that boost your productivity and give you a competitive edge. Explore now to discover your perfect tool!
9 tools
xix.ai
Comments (31)
0/500
![JuanEvans]()
It's wild how AI startups are turning peer review into a PR stunt! 😅 Sakana and others submitting AI-generated studies to ICLR is bold, but it feels like they're more focused on headlines than real science. Anyone else think this could backfire big time?
![LawrenceMiller]()
Я в замешательстве по поводу этих исследований, созданных ИИ, на ICLR. С одной стороны, круто, что ИИ может генерировать исследования, но использовать это для PR? Это кажется немного неправильным. Это расширяет границы, но не уверен, что это лучший способ.
![AlbertAllen]()
I'm kinda torn about these AI startups using peer review as a PR move. On one hand, it's clever marketing, but on the other, it feels like they're gaming the system. I mean, if the studies are legit, why not just say so? Feels a bit shady to me.
![JackMartin]()
ICLRでのAI生成の研究論文について、複雑な気持ちです。AIが研究を生成できるのは面白いけど、PRに利用するのは少し違和感があります。境界を押し広げる試みではあるけど、必ずしも最良の方法とは言えないかもしれませんね。
![JonathanKing]()
Estoy dividido sobre estas startups de IA que usan la revisión por pares como una táctica de relaciones públicas. Por un lado, es un marketing inteligente, pero por otro, parece que están jugando con el sistema. Si los estudios son legítimos, ¿por qué no decirlo simplemente? Me parece un poco turbio.
![BillyThomas]()
Me siento dividido con lo de los estudios generados por IA en ICLR. Por un lado, es genial que la IA pueda producir investigación, pero usarlo para relaciones públicas, no sé, me parece un poco fuera de lugar. Está empujando límites, pero no estoy seguro de que sea de la mejor manera.
Bayer Leverages Iambic AI to Speed Drug Discovery
Juergen Eckhardt, M.D., serves as Head of Business Development and Licensing at Bayer Pharmaceuticals.Bayer is leveraging Iambic Therapeutics to deploy frontier AI models for drug discovery, alongside a major decarbonization project at its plant in S
Optimization-Driven AI Emerges as New Path to General-Purpose Models
Researchers from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and the University of Virginia have created a new model architecture that could pave the way for more resilient AI systems with enhanced reasoning power.Named the energy-based transformer (
AI Boom Echoes Dot-Com Era Bubble Concerns
The influx of multi-billion dollar investments into AI has fueled a heated debate: is the industry headed for a dot-com style bubble?Investors are vigilant for any cooling of enthusiasm or signs that massive spending on chips and infrastructure isn't
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI SERP Analysis Tools for Search Strategy are curated by XIX.AI through rigorous real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. These powerful tools help you unlock hidden optimization opportunities, boost content performance, and gain a competitive edge in search. Discover your perfect tool to elevate your search strategy today. Explore now!
13 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Anomaly Detection Tools for KPI Monitoring in SaaS and Ecommerce teams! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection based on rigorous real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison insights to help you identify the must-try solution that boosts productivity and unlocks your AI edge. Explore now!
10 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Outline Generators for Long-Form SEO Articles, meticulously curated by XIX.AI. These powerful tools offer game-changing assistance in creating high-quality content quickly, boosting writing efficiency significantly. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and detailed rankings to help you find the must-try option that suits your needs. Explore now to unlock your AI edge.
8 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best AI Study Tools for Homework and Exam Prep! XIX.AI curates a top-rated list of powerful, game-changing tools that help students boost productivity, streamline homework completion, and ace exams through real-world tests. Get a free vs paid comparison, detailed rankings, and must-try options to unlock your AI edge. Explore now!
10 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best AI Vocal Demo Tools for Songwriters, Hook Creators, and Multi-Language Content Teams! XIX.AI has curated a top-rated list of powerful game-changing tools that go through rigorous real-world tests. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison data, comprehensive rankings, and must-try options to help you boost writing efficiency and unlock your creative potential. Explore now to discover your perfect tool for all your content needs!
9 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Competitive Research Tools for Small Businesses! XIX.AI has curated a highly powerful game-changing collection, updated weekly with rigorous real-world tests and detailed rankings. You can find a comprehensive free vs paid comparison to help you identify the must-try tools that boost your productivity and give you a competitive edge. Explore now to discover your perfect tool!
9 tools
xix.ai
It's wild how AI startups are turning peer review into a PR stunt! 😅 Sakana and others submitting AI-generated studies to ICLR is bold, but it feels like they're more focused on headlines than real science. Anyone else think this could backfire big time?
Я в замешательстве по поводу этих исследований, созданных ИИ, на ICLR. С одной стороны, круто, что ИИ может генерировать исследования, но использовать это для PR? Это кажется немного неправильным. Это расширяет границы, но не уверен, что это лучший способ.
I'm kinda torn about these AI startups using peer review as a PR move. On one hand, it's clever marketing, but on the other, it feels like they're gaming the system. I mean, if the studies are legit, why not just say so? Feels a bit shady to me.
ICLRでのAI生成の研究論文について、複雑な気持ちです。AIが研究を生成できるのは面白いけど、PRに利用するのは少し違和感があります。境界を押し広げる試みではあるけど、必ずしも最良の方法とは言えないかもしれませんね。
Estoy dividido sobre estas startups de IA que usan la revisión por pares como una táctica de relaciones públicas. Por un lado, es un marketing inteligente, pero por otro, parece que están jugando con el sistema. Si los estudios son legítimos, ¿por qué no decirlo simplemente? Me parece un poco turbio.
Me siento dividido con lo de los estudios generados por IA en ICLR. Por un lado, es genial que la IA pueda producir investigación, pero usarlo para relaciones públicas, no sé, me parece un poco fuera de lugar. Está empujando límites, pero no estoy seguro de que sea de la mejor manera.
